By: Regan Quaal & Jesper Mårtensson
Edited by: Amy Hobday
We have all probably said to ourselves when performing a conditioning session “I will do this for X amount of time or do these intervals for X amount of time”. On the other hand, we have also most likely said to ourselves when performing a weight room session “I will do this exercise for X repetitions”. The question is: Why are we only prescribing duration for conditioning and not for exercises? Both serve the exact same purpose, preparing an athlete to compete in sport, so why do we differ between the two?
They should not be thought of as separate entities because all qualities can be developed using both scenarios, especially when it comes to preparing an athlete from an energy system profile perspective. Sport is timed by duration, not by number of repetitions, so using timed sets for the weight room makes much more sense if we are trying to develop training programs that are specific to the demands of sport. On top of that, utilizing time will control for the possible variance in training volumes amongst your athletes and is the best method to develop repeat sprint ability.
ENERGY SYSTEM BASICS
Before we continue with the practical application and reasoning for timing your sets, we want to touch back on what we wrote in the first paragraph, “Sport is timed by duration, not by number of repetitions''. When training athletes on the field or in the weight room, the three energy systems that we look to develop are the oxidative system, the lactic system, and the alactic system. Each plays an important role in the complete development of every athlete. In the following paragraphs, we will relate each energy system to a different sport for simplicity's sake.
The oxidative system can be thought of as the energy system a cross country runner primarily relies upon in their sport. This is because the duration of their events are typically 15 or more minutes, and the efforts performed during their events are of a consistent, sustained nature. The oxidative system takes over energy demands in any activity lasting more than 3 minutes in a sport with continuous work, gradually relying more so on fat as a fuel than carbohydrates as the event goes on.
The lactic system is what a hockey player primarily relies on for energy demands. This is because a shift in hockey lasts roughly 45 seconds and is performed at a moderate high intensity. The lactic system is primarily responsible for providing energy for moderate to high intensity efforts that last over 10 seconds and up to 3 minutes. The aerobic system cannot provide enough energy fast enough for these bouts, so the lactic system relies more so on carbs than fats for this reason.
The alactic system is what a sport like American Football primarily relies on because the majority of plays last less than 10 seconds and are always performed at maximal effort. These maximal outputs can only be supplied by the alactic system because immediate, available energy from PCr is required to fuel them.
Figure 1. Energy system pyramid.
ENERGY SYSTEM PYRAMID
The pyramid above (Figure 1) demonstrates how all of the energy systems are tied together and just as with any pyramid, the first step is creating a wide base because the wider the base, the higher the peak. This base is the oxidative system because it is what gives us the ability to train more frequently at higher volumes and helps us recover from training. This is an important first step to develop before going forward because having the ability to train and recover from more volume gives you the ability to make stronger adaptations.
The next step up the pyramid is the lactic energy system, which is the moderate intensity/moderate duration effort. We won't elaborate much on this topic, but generally speaking, sport covers this base with the way practices are performed. The stop and go nature of practice and learning of new strategy/skill results in moderate intensity efforts with incomplete rest.
Lastly is the peak of the pyramid: the alactic system. This may be the most important box to check in your training because it is difficult to accomplish in practice with any team sport, and it has the largest carry over to high performance in most sports. Due to how much skill and strategy is required in sport, most efforts aren’t truly maximal because you have to be conscious of many other factors. The beauty of sport performance within a weight room is that it allows the athletes to give maximal effort during low-skill movements (such as linear sprints, trap bar deadlifts, or bench press). In this way, the alactic system can be trained very effectively to raise the athletes' overall athletic ceiling. We perform training like this to raise our ceiling with this physical quality.
In sport, one of the largest factors that decides who will come out on top at the end of a competition is which team can perform high effort sprints (bouts) over and over. This is especially important at the end of the game when fatigue starts to become a larger factor. This ability is often referred to as repeated sprint ability, and it is one of the main adaptations we all hope to develop with our athletes.
MAXIMIZING TRAINING DENSITY
As we have mentioned, success in sport comes from being able to produce max efforts repeatedly throughout an entire competition. For an athlete to be able to accomplish this, there are some primary prerequisites they must develop during their training in the off-season:
Once these have been developed, the outcome is an athlete who is able to train both very hard for short periods of time and also able to train for a very long time at low intensities. The goal then is to combine these two qualities into one, by developing an athlete that can train very hard for short periods of time over and over again.
The easiest way we have to develop an athlete with this ability in our opinion is setting up every training session including the weight room as something with an underlying conditioning goal. The underlying conditioning goal in the weight room is to improve the training density that the athlete can tolerate. Training density is the number of sets and repetitions performed within a certain time frame. If we improve this number with our athletes week to week and keep the quality of the training high then we are destined to be preparing the athletes for their sport.
REPEAT SPRINT ABILITY
In team sports, the deciding factor in competition is a team’s ability to perform high quality repeat sprints throughout a game, especially as it comes to an end. Just to clarify - when we talk about repeat sprint ability we aren’t only referring to sprinting, but to any high intensity effort that may take place like swinging a bat, jumping to spike a volleyball, or driving into a defender you are intending to block. Given the versatility of repeat sprint ability, one might think of it more as repeat max output ability. For the sake of this article, a max output is an effort that is up to 10 seconds, which means we are referring to the alactic system (peak of the pyramid) that we discussed earlier in this article.
This is essential for team sport because there are many crucial moments that take place during a game that go far beyond just sprinting in a straight line. That is why we have found it so important to develop a style of training that will prepare an athlete holistically for performing max outputs with their entire body. Also, performing sprints is probably the best overall way to improve this ability, but when athletes are already running so much in their sport it may not be the smartest way to train it. In addition, it is likely that it will not provide enough volume to fully develop this quality. That is why we have resorted to using timed sets in the weight room to further develop this adaptation.
WHY USE TIMED SETS IN THE WEIGHT ROOM
The most common prescription for volume in the weight room is repetitions. Repetitions were established to make it easier for everyone to understand and apply exercise volume to the masses. Instead of utilizing seconds, people argued that it was easier to describe with repetitions, which in reality is easier because nobody wants to have to stare at a clock or timer or count out loud to themselves or to their partner during every set they perform. Using repetitions allows everyone to be on their own clock and work at their own pace. Allow each individual to allot as much time as they want between reps during the isometric or “resting” portion of the movement and make each rep last as long as they want. One of the many incidents that we have seen in the weight room relating to this issue is an athlete going for a heavy 5 on a squat and resting 5-10 seconds between reps just to grind out another slow, choppy rep. Making a set that should last roughly 20 seconds last up to a minute
Using reps is perfectly fine for an individual training on their own or someone getting trained that does not have any specific goals or needs. This is the case if the individual just wants to feel like they had a “good” workout, making it the practical thing for them to do. This is not the case for individual athletes with specific goals or athletes in a team setting with specific goals.
If we want the training programs we have created to be as effective as possible, we need them to be executed as specific as possible for the individuals/teams goals or needs. If we are not exactly certain of what training our athletes have completed, we are unable to understand the effect our training program had on our athletes performance. This makes it challenging to decipher which part of the program played a role in the changes that take place in post-test and retest with our athletes.
That is why we have found using timed sets for most of the exercises in the weight room to be the most effective means of exercise prescription. It makes sure all athletes are given the same stimulus. Going back to what we mentioned above, 5 reps for one athlete may be taxing a completely different energy system than another athlete if their intent towards their exercises is much different.
On top of it keeping set duration uniform for all athletes, it removes many common faults that take place in the weight room, like:
WEIGHT ROOM TIMED SETS: MAXIMIZE REPEAT SPRINT ABILITY
When training repeat sprint ability, the goal is to keep intensity as high as possible for sets that last anywhere between 5-10 seconds in order to develop the alactic energy system. This is difficult to prescribe using repetitions as our metric for volume. For example, as mentioned before, prescribing 3-4 repetitions to the athletes can lead to many different outcomes. One athlete may complete the work in 6-8 seconds, while it takes around 15 seconds for another athlete. This means that two different energy systems will be trained by different athletes for the same set during the same workout, so the stimulus is not uniform amongst all of your athletes. To understand the effect the program is having on the athletes, we have to make sure that the intended quality is being trained.
In our experience, prescribing volume through time instead of repetitions increases the repeat sprint ability of a team. This happens because the focus of each set shifts from moving as much load as possible for the prescribed repetitions to moving the prescribed weight at the fastest rate possible for the prescribed time domain.
To control the rate of movement during the timed sets, we use different percentages based on our goal for the training. The idea behind using percentages in a timed set system is to control the rate of movement during the set by adjusting the weight being used for each set. This only works, however, if the athlete is always applying max intent to every set therefore regardless of load, they are trying to move the weight as fast as possible. Naturally it causes the athlete to move at a faster or slower rate depending on the percentage being used.
The only issue with using the load to control rate of movement is the exercises you choose to use to improve repeat sprint ability must be mastered from a technical standpoint by the athlete. When we program exercises for the purpose of improving repeat sprint ability, we normally select ones that are simple to execute and can be performed by a wide variety of athletes. Therefore, athletes don’t have to learn another complex skill in addition to their sport skills. This minimizes the need for making individual variations in the workout. Also, if it takes the athletes an extended period of time simply to learn how to perform the exercise, then we are going to be wasting the majority of our off-season teaching movement in exercises that are difficult to execute. Instead of using ones that can be performed by a wide variety of athletes that will lead to adaptations at a faster rate.
Another benefit of performing the majority of your repeat sprint training in the weight room using timed sets is you can apply it to more than just the lower body.. It can be applied to all the major movement patterns or muscle groups that you train, if you can select the correct exercises that can be performed with max intent safely.
Lastly, we have found this type of training to be most important for more veteran athletes with higher training ages who are most likely strong enough already and need to focus on other training qualities. The other qualities are power, speed, and repeat sprint capacity.
TIMED SETS PRACTICAL APPLICATION
If we take a look at the duration of each energy system, they are primarily working over a specific period of time. e.g. the alactic system is dominant from 1 to 10 seconds. This leaves us with the question, how do we determine the length of the set? We like to categorize it into two categories: either quality or capacity focus. If the purpose of the exercise is to perform high quality repetitions, you would perform the exercise at the bottom range of the time frame. If the purpose of the exercise is to build capacity, you would perform the exercise at the top range of the time frame. However, if you have an athlete that is well balanced, you would probably have them go somewhere in the middle of the time frame or have them focus on each during different days each week.
How do we apply energy system training to a workout? First,we decide what the main goal is for the workout of the day. Is it to improve speed or increase the tolerance to lactate e.g which energy system is primarily responsible. Second, we identify if the athlete needs to improve high quality repetitions (power) or if the athlete needs to improve capacity (conditioning) in that certain energy system. Third, we decide which exercise to which we are going to apply the specific energy system training which is dependent on the goal of the exercise. Understanding the purpose of each exercise is essential for designing a proper program.
What are some exercises where you can implement a timed set? Below is a list of a few exercises where we have found success implementing timed sets. These are just some examples because we don't want to leave you hanging and we want you to experiment on your own. We have also included two complexes that train the alactic system to demonstrate how you can combine timed sets with repetitions sets.
Example on exercises where you can implement timed sets:
1A) Squat x10s
1B) Box Jumps x4
2A) Bench Press x10s
2B) MB Throw x4
A few of you might even be skeptical of this approach because you have always used repetitions for keeping track of volume. To all of you, you have to remember that sport is timed by duration, not by the number of repetitions. By timing your sets athletes get different amounts of volume during a workout depending on how well trained they are. You could even argue that timed sets are a more individualized approach. Most important of all, timed sets will increase repeat sprint ability which is crucial in sport due to the high intensity bouts. We hope that you have learned something new and when you have processed this new information, hopefully start to implement timed sets.
Head Strength & Conditioning Coach at Shakopee High School